Life Care Plan vs. Medicare Set-Aside Allocation

Reviewed by KW Life Care Planning Editorial Team · Last updated

Life Care Plan

A comprehensive projection of all injury-related future medical and non-medical needs and their cost across the expected lifespan, prepared for litigation, mediation, or settlement (Reavis, 2002).

Learn more about Life Care Plan

Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) Allocation

An estimate of the portion of a settlement to reserve for future injury-related care that Medicare would otherwise pay, prepared under Medicare's review guidance (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, 2026).

Learn more about Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) Allocation

DimensionLife Care PlanMedicare Set-Aside (MSA) Allocation
PurposeQuantify the full cost of future care as damagesProtect Medicare's interest when a settlement closes future medical
AudienceTrier of fact, mediator, adjusterSettling parties, CMS reviewer, professional administrator
ScopeAll injury-related needs, medical and non-medicalMedicare-covered, injury-related items only
Pricing basisCost of care in the evaluee's market, documented per itemFee schedule or usual-and-customary per Medicare guidance
HorizonPopulation life expectancy unless a physician adjusts itLife expectancy or an underwriter's rated age
Typical sizeLargerSmaller; a subset of the plan

When to use Life Care Plan

Prepare a life care plan whenever future care is a significant component of damages in a personal injury, malpractice, or catastrophic injury matter, whether the case is headed to trial or settlement.

When to use Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) Allocation

Prepare an MSA allocation when a workers' compensation or liability settlement involves a Medicare beneficiary or someone with a reasonable expectation of enrollment and the settlement releases future medical care.

Where they overlap

Both start from the same medical record and the same treating-team recommendations, and the same planner can prepare both. The allocation is best understood as a carve-out from the plan: the subset of items Medicare would cover, priced the way Medicare's guidance expects. Many catastrophic workers' compensation cases need both, and preparing them from a single record review keeps the two documents consistent.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the MSA simply be the life care plan total?

No. The plan includes care Medicare does not cover and prices items at market cost rather than fee schedule. Using the plan total as the set-aside overstates the reserve and does not follow Medicare's guidance.

Does every settlement with a Medicare beneficiary need an MSA?

Medicare's interests must be considered whenever future medical care is released. Whether a formal allocation is prepared, and whether it is submitted for review, depends on the settlement amount, the beneficiary's status, and counsel's judgment.

Which comes first?

Usually the life care plan, because it establishes the complete inventory of future needs. The allocation is then derived from that inventory by removing non-covered and unrelated items and re-pricing what remains.

References

Discuss how this applies to your case

KW Life Care Planning provides independent, objective life care planning analysis for plaintiff and defense counsel nationwide. Tell us about the matter and we will scope the appropriate deliverable, or explore the relevant practice area below.

Request a Consultation or call (201) 343-0700.